top of page

Scaphoid Fracture Treatment in London

A scaphoid fracture is a break in the scaphoid, a small boat-shaped bone on the thumb side of the wrist. It is the most commonly broken of the small wrist bones, and most happen after a fall onto an outstretched hand.

These fractures can hide on X-rays taken in the first days after injury, so a painful wrist after a fall needs review even when the first X-ray looks normal. Found in the first weeks, most heal in a cast. A missed fracture can fail to join and lead to arthritis in the wrist.

Book a consultation

 

Symptoms

  • Pain on the thumb side of the wrist after a fall

  • Tenderness in the hollow at the base of the thumb (the anatomical snuffbox)

  • Pain when gripping, pushing up from a chair or twisting the wrist

  • Mild swelling

The wrist can still move well and swelling can be slight, which is why this injury is mistaken for a sprain.

 

Why scaphoid fractures matter

The scaphoid has a limited blood supply, which enters from the end nearest the thumb. A break can cut off the blood supply to the other end of the bone, so some fractures heal slowly or not at all. A fracture that fails to join (a non-union) can lead the wrist bones to collapse and cause arthritis over the years that follow.

Fractures nearer the forearm end of the bone (the proximal pole) carry the highest risk.

 

How is a scaphoid fracture diagnosed?

I examine the wrist for tenderness over the scaphoid and pain on pressing along the thumb.

  • X-rays with dedicated scaphoid views show most fractures, but not all in the first days.

  • MRI is the test of choice when X-rays are normal but a fracture is suspected, as NICE recommends. A Cochrane review found that a positive MRI or CT is reliable, and that MRI detects more hidden fractures than CT.

  • CT scans show the position of the fracture and whether it has healed.

If a fracture is suspected, I advise a splint until the scan result is known, rather than waiting for symptoms to settle.

 

Non-surgical treatment

Most fractures of the waist of the scaphoid that are in a good position heal in a cast.

  1. Cast or splint. A below-elbow cast for about 6 weeks for most waist fractures.

  2. Scan to confirm healing. A CT scan at the end of the cast period shows whether the bone has joined.

  3. Hand therapy. Exercises to restore movement and strength once the bone has healed.

In the SWIFFT trial of 439 adults with scaphoid waist fractures displaced by no more than 2 mm, a cast with prompt surgery for any fracture that failed to heal gave the same wrist function at one year as surgery for everyone. Most patients in the cast group avoided an operation.

 

Surgery and recovery

I recommend surgery when a fracture:

  • Is displaced by more than 2 mm, or unstable

  • Involves the proximal pole

  • Was diagnosed late

  • Has not healed in a cast (non-union)

For an athlete or manual worker, early fixation can mean a shorter time in a cast. I discuss the trade-offs with you.

The operation

  • Day-case procedure under general or regional anaesthetic

  • A compression screw holds the bone, placed through a small incision or a cut of a few millimetres

  • For a non-union, the bone ends are cleaned and a bone graft from the wrist or hip helps the bone join

  • The operation takes 45 to 90 minutes

Recovery timeline

After a cast: cast for about 6 weeks; CT scan to confirm healing; hand therapy for 4 to 6 weeks; return to sport and heavy work at about 3 months.

After screw fixation, 0 to 2 weeks: Splint and wound check. Return to desk work.

2 to 6 weeks: Removable splint and gentle movement as your hand therapist directs.

6 to 12 weeks: CT scan to confirm healing; strengthening begins. Driving once you can grip the wheel with control; see Driving after hand or wrist surgery.

3 months: Return to contact sport and heavy work once the scan shows healing.

After non-union surgery: healing takes longer, with a cast or splint for 8 to 12 weeks.

Risks include the bone not healing, loss of blood supply to part of the bone, stiffness and arthritis. After surgery, risks include infection, a prominent screw and irritation of a small skin nerve.

 

When to see a specialist

See a hand specialist if:

  • Your wrist is still painful a week after a fall, even with a normal X-ray

  • You are tender in the hollow at the base of your thumb

  • You were told it was a sprain and it is not settling

  • An X-ray or scan shows a scaphoid fracture

  • Your wrist is still painful after a cast for a scaphoid fracture

  • You injured your wrist months or years ago and now have a painful, stiff wrist

 

Frequently asked questions

My X-ray was normal. Could my scaphoid still be broken?

Yes. Scaphoid fractures can be invisible on X-rays in the first days. If you are tender in the hollow at the base of the thumb, an MRI scan can confirm or rule out a fracture.

Will I need surgery?

Most scaphoid fractures in a good position heal in a cast. Surgery is for displaced or unstable fractures, proximal pole fractures and fractures that do not heal.

How long does a scaphoid fracture take to heal?

About 6 to 12 weeks for most fractures, and longer for proximal pole fractures and non-unions. A CT scan confirms healing before you return to heavy use.

Can I play sport in a cast?

It depends on the sport and the rules. Some sports allow a padded cast. I discuss this with you, as heavy use before the bone has joined risks it not healing.

I broke my wrist years ago and it never healed. Can it be treated?

In many cases, yes. A scaphoid non-union can be repaired with a bone graft and a screw. If arthritis has developed, other operations can relieve pain.

Do I need a GP referral?

Many insurers require one for a claim. Self-funding patients can book direct, and an X-ray report or scan helps.

 

About the author

Written by Mr Dafydd (Taff) Edwards, BSc MBBS FRCS MD DMCC, Consultant Trauma and Orthopaedic Surgeon specialising in hand, wrist and elbow surgery at Cleveland Clinic London, and Chair of the British Society for Surgery of the Hand (BSSH) Trauma Committee. GMC number: 4767853.

Last reviewed: 17 November 2026. Next review: November 2027.

 

Book a consultation

Cleveland Clinic London, 55 Moorgate, London EC2R 6BH.

Book a consultation. Call 0203 423 7183 or email DEdwardsMedSec@ccf.org

 

References

  1. Dias JJ, Brealey SD, Fairhurst C, et al. Surgery versus cast immobilisation for adults with a bicortical fracture of the scaphoid waist (SWIFFT): a pragmatic, multicentre, open-label, randomised superiority trial. Lancet. 2020;396(10248):390-401.

  2. Mallee WH, Wang J, Poolman RW, et al. Computed tomography versus magnetic resonance imaging versus bone scintigraphy for clinically suspected scaphoid fractures in patients with negative plain radiographs. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2015;(6):CD010023.

  3. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Fractures (non-complex): assessment and management. NICE guideline NG38. 2016.

bottom of page